Construction Workers Compensation: Year-End FAQ for Contractors

Construction workers compensation is often the largest premium on a contractor’s account. It is also the line most likely to surprise you after the policy ends. With year-end audits and January 1 renewals coming up, now is a good time to check it.

This FAQ is for owners of growing contractors with several crews. We answer the questions we hear most about mods, audits and class codes.

Construction workers compensation for a growing Illinois contractor

Who Needs Construction Workers Compensation in Illinois?

Nearly every employer does. In Illinois, even one part-time employee triggers the rule. Also, coverage must start on day one. (Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission)

Construction gets extra attention. Some owners and LLC members may opt out in other fields. However, construction and other extra-hazardous firms generally must carry coverage. Employers who knowingly go without it face fines of up to $500 a day, with a $10,000 minimum. In addition, the state can issue a stop-work order.

How Does the Experience Mod Affect Construction Workers Compensation?

Your experience mod compares your losses to similar employers. A mod of 1.00 is average. Below 1.00 is a credit, which lowers your premium. Above 1.00 is a debit, which raises it. (NCCI)

The mod usually uses three years of payroll and losses. It skips the current policy. So a claim this year can affect your price for years.

Small claims affect construction workers compensation costs more than many owners think. The formula weighs how often you have claims more than how big they are. In other words, many small claims can hurt more than one large one. On the other hand, medical-only claims count at just 30%. So report injuries fast, and get workers care early.

Also, a high mod can cost you work. Some owners won’t let you bid with a mod above 1.00. Even so, NCCI says the mod was built to price premium, not to rank safety. (NCCI)

Why Did My Construction Workers Compensation Audit Go Up?

Your construction workers compensation premium starts as an estimate. After the term ends, the carrier audits your actual payroll. Then it bills or refunds the difference.

Audits usually jump for three reasons:

  1. Payroll grew. You added crews or gave raises during the year.
  2. Uninsured subs. If a sub had no comp, the auditor may add their pay to yours.
  3. Wrong class codes. Office staff landed in field codes, or the other way around.

Therefore, keep your records clean all year. Track sub certificates, split payroll by class and keep overtime records. Under NCCI rules, the extra “half” of time-and-a-half can often be left out if your records show it.

What Are the Classification Traps?

In construction workers compensation, class codes set your rate per $100 of payroll. Roofing and steel codes cost far more than carpentry or office codes. So one misplaced worker can swing your bill.

The most common traps include:

  • Putting a field supervisor in a clerical code
  • Splitting one worker’s pay across codes without records to back it up
  • Treating crew members as 1099 contractors

That last one is costly in Illinois. The Employee Classification Act presumes construction workers are employees. To call someone independent, a contractor must meet a three-part test. Penalties can reach $1,500 per violation. Also, each day can count as a new violation. (Illinois Department of Labor)

How Can Contractors Lower Construction Workers Compensation Costs?

There is no single fix. However, these steps often help:

  • Write a safety program, and put one person in charge
  • Offer light-duty work so injured workers return sooner
  • Report every injury to your carrier the same day
  • Collect comp certificates from every sub before work starts
  • Review class codes with your agent before each renewal
  • Use the carrier’s safety services, which are often free

Next, think about the market. Some carriers write comp as part of a whole-account package with general liability, auto and umbrella. Others focus on comp for skilled trades. As an independent agency, we can compare both. Learn more on our workers’ compensation page. Also see how comp fits a full general contractors insurance program.

A Year-End Construction Workers Compensation Checklist

Before December 31, set aside 30 minutes with your office manager. Then work through this list:

  1. Pull current comp certificates for every sub you paid this year
  2. Flag any sub whose policy lapsed during a job
  3. Check that each worker sits in the right class code
  4. Total overtime pay apart from regular pay
  5. Get your loss runs and your new mod worksheet
  6. Tell your agent about any payroll growth now

As a result, your audit goes faster. You also walk into renewal with fewer surprises.

More Construction Workers Compensation Questions

When does a new experience mod take effect?

Usually on your policy’s renewal date. So ask for your mod worksheet before renewal and check it for errors.

Can I exclude myself as the owner?

Sometimes. Illinois lets some owners and officers opt out. However, construction firms face stricter rules, so ask first.

Do I need comp for 1099 workers?

Often, yes. Illinois presumes construction workers are employees unless all three tests are met. Otherwise, your carrier may charge for them at audit.

What should I bring to my audit?

Bring payroll by class, overtime records, sub certificates and sub payments. Also bring your quarterly payroll tax forms.

Should my comp be with the same carrier as my liability?

Often, it helps. One carrier for the whole account can mean one renewal and one claims team. Still, a comp specialist may fit high-hazard trades better. So compare both at renewal.

Get a Construction Workers Compensation Review

Year-end is the best time to fix class codes and sub files. We can review your mod, your last audit and your renewal in one meeting. Request a commercial quote or call Weer Insurance Group at 773-545-2001.

Read More

Subcontractor Risk Transfer: How GCs Protect Their Program

Subcontractor risk transfer is how a general contractor moves job risk onto the subs who create it. When it works, a sub’s mistake lands on the sub’s policy. When it fails, the claim lands on yours. As a result, your loss runs, your premium and even your next bid can take the hit.

This guide is for owners of multi-crew general contractors and construction managers. If you run $5 million to $50 million of work a year, your subs likely do most of it. So here is how strong firms set up contracts, certificates and endorsements. We also show where the gaps usually hide.

Subcontractor risk transfer for a Chicago general contractor

What Subcontractor Risk Transfer Means

Risk transfer uses three tools. First, the subcontract, with its indemnity clause. Second, insurance rules, such as additional insured status. Third, a tracking system that proves each sub actually complied.

Each tool backs up the others. For example, an indemnity clause is only as good as the sub’s ability to pay. By contrast, additional insured status gives you direct rights under the sub’s policy. In other words, you become an insured on their policy, not just a name in a contract.

Underwriters notice this. Carriers that write mid-size contractors often ask how you manage subs before they quote. So a clean process can mean better terms at renewal.

Start With a Written Subcontract

Subcontractor risk transfer starts with paper. Many additional insured endorsements only respond when a written contract requires them. For example, the blanket form CG 20 33 needs a written deal between your sub and you. Without one, you may have no coverage at all. (Insurance Journal)

So sign the subcontract before the sub sets foot on site. Don’t wait for the first pay app. Also, use the same core terms on every job. Then review them each year with your attorney.

A strong subcontract usually spells out:

  • Required coverages and minimum limits
  • Additional insured status for ongoing and completed work
  • Primary and non-contributory wording
  • A waiver of subrogation on each line
  • How long completed operations coverage must stay in place
  • Who must be named: you, the owner, the lender and others the prime contract lists

Illinois Rules That Shape Subcontractor Risk Transfer

Illinois adds a twist. Its Construction Contract Indemnification for Negligence Act voids any promise to indemnify someone for their own negligence. (740 ILCS 35/1) In other words, the indemnity clause can’t make a sub pay for your own mistakes.

However, the Act does not apply to insurance contracts or agreements. (Taft Law) That is why additional insured status carries so much weight here. Still, courts can void an insurance clause tied too closely to a bad indemnity clause. Therefore, keep the two clauses separate.

There is one more wrinkle, called the Kotecki cap. Say a sub’s worker is hurt and sues you. You can then seek contribution from the sub. But that amount is usually capped at the sub’s workers’ comp benefits. Some subcontracts ask the sub to waive that cap. Ask your attorney whether that fits your contracts.

Additional Insured Endorsements for Ongoing and Completed Work

The certificate is not the coverage. The endorsement is.

Most construction programs use two ISO forms. The CG 20 10 covers you during the sub’s ongoing work. The CG 20 37 covers you after the work is done. Older CG 20 10 editions covered both. Newer ones only cover ongoing work. (Insurance Journal) As a result, a sub with only a CG 20 10 can leave you exposed once they leave the site.

That gap matters. Many defect claims show up years after a job closes. So require completed operations coverage. Also require it for a set number of years after the job ends.

Next, watch the blanket forms. The CG 20 38 can extend coverage up the chain to the owner and others your contract names. However, many carriers use their own versions. So read the actual wording.

Primary Wording and Waiver of Subrogation

Additional insured status is only one part of subcontractor risk transfer. Next, ask whose policy pays first.

Primary and non-contributory wording means the sub’s policy responds before yours. It also keeps the sub’s carrier from asking yours to share. Without it, the two carriers may split the loss. Consequently, your loss runs still take a hit.

A waiver of subrogation stops the sub’s carrier from suing you after it pays a claim. Ask for it on every line, including workers’ comp. In addition, check that the sub’s umbrella follows the same terms. Some umbrellas only extend coverage when the contract requires it.

Certificates Are Not Enough

A certificate of insurance is a snapshot. It shows a policy existed on the day it was issued. However, it does not change the policy. In fact, it may not even show which endorsements are attached.

So collect more than the certificate. Strong GCs ask for:

  1. The certificate, with your firm and the owner named correctly
  2. Copies of the additional insured endorsements
  3. The primary and waiver endorsements
  4. Proof of workers’ comp, or a valid exemption
  5. Umbrella certificates when the contract calls for them

Then track expiration dates. A policy that lapses mid-job leaves you open. Many firms now use software or a service to chase renewals. Either way, one person in your office should own the process.

Uninsured Subs and Your Workers’ Comp Audit

Here is a cost many GCs miss. If a sub has no workers’ comp, your carrier may treat their crew as yours at audit. As a result, you pay comp premium on their payroll.

Illinois also presumes that people doing construction work are employees. Under the Employee Classification Act, a contractor must meet a three-part test to treat someone as independent. Penalties can reach $1,500 per violation, and each day can count separately. (Illinois Department of Labor)

Therefore, make comp certificates part of your subcontractor risk transfer process. Collect one from every sub, every year. Also, be careful with one-person subs who claim an exemption. Ask your agent before you accept one. For more, see our workers’ compensation page.

Matching Sub Limits to the Job

Not every sub needs the same limits. A painter on a small tenant job is not a crane crew on a mid-rise. So build tiers into your subcontractor risk transfer rules.

For example, many GCs use three levels:

  • Low-hazard trades: $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate
  • Mid-hazard trades: the same, plus an umbrella of a few million
  • High-hazard trades like roofing, steel and excavation: higher umbrella limits, often $5 million or more

Next, match your tiers to your own contracts. If an owner wants $10 million from you, your biggest subs may need more too. For Chicago license limits, see our guide to Chicago contractor licensing insurance.

How Subcontractor Risk Transfer Affects Your Premium

Your own general liability is often rated on payroll, sales or subcontracted costs. Also, many carriers charge more for subs who are uninsured or underinsured. In other words, a sloppy file can raise your rate.

On the other hand, a strong program helps. Signed contracts, endorsements and a tracking log show underwriters less risk. As a result, more carriers may compete for your account. For the full picture, see our general contractors insurance page. You can also review the basics of general liability insurance.

Subcontractor Risk Transfer FAQ

Is a certificate of insurance enough to protect my firm?

Usually not. A certificate only summarizes a policy. So ask for the actual additional insured, primary and waiver endorsements too.

Can I require Illinois subs to name me as additional insured?

In general, yes. The state’s anti-indemnity law voids clauses that make a sub pay for your own negligence. However, it does not apply to insurance agreements. Still, have your attorney review the wording.

How long should completed operations coverage last?

Many GCs require it for several years after the job closes. Match it to your warranty and to how long defect claims can be filed. Your attorney can set the right number.

What happens if a sub has no workers’ comp?

Your carrier may charge you for their payroll at audit. You could also face a claim if their worker is hurt. So collect a comp certificate before work starts.

Should every sub carry the same limits?

No. Many GCs set limits by trade hazard and job size. As a rule, high-hazard trades carry more.

Get a Subcontractor Risk Transfer Review

If your firm has grown, your sub requirements should grow with it. We can review your subcontract, your certificate process and your own program in one meeting. Then we will show you where the gaps are. Request a commercial quote or call Weer Insurance Group at 773-545-2001.

Read More

Builder’s Risk Insurance for Winter Construction in Chicago

Construction in Chicago doesn’t stop when temperatures drop. Framing, drywall, and concrete work often continue under tarps and plastic sheeting with temporary heaters running around the clock. However, that setup keeps a schedule on track, but it also concentrates several distinct risks in one partially finished building. Builder’s risk insurance can help with the build.

Matching Winter Risks to the Right Policy

Risk Coverage that usually responds What to confirm
Fire damaging the structure or stored materials Builder’s risk insurance Any heater or fire safety conditions written into the policy
Fire or smoke spreading to a neighboring property General liability Limits that fit a dense block with attached buildings
A worker overcome by carbon monoxide Workers’ compensation That every crew, including subs, carries their own coverage
Pipes freezing in an unfinished space Builder’s risk, depending on terms Whether the policy requires heat to be maintained

The Conditions Many Contractors Overlook

Some builder’s risk policies include protective safeguard requirements, such as keeping heaters attended, maintaining clearances from combustibles, or having extinguishers on each floor. These aren’t suggestions. Falling short of a written condition can complicate a claim, so it’s worth reading that section before the first cold snap.

A Short Cold-Weather Site Routine

  • Keep heaters clear of tarps, lumber, and insulation
  • Ventilate enclosed areas and use carbon monoxide detectors
  • Assign someone to check heaters at the end of each shift
  • Store propane cylinders according to the manufacturer’s and code guidance

Weer Insurance Group works with contractors across Chicago, from Portage Park to the collar counties, to line up general contractors’ insurance that fits year-round work. To review your builder’s risk insurance conditions before winter, stop by our Belmont Avenue office or reach out through Weer Insurance Group in Chicago, IL.

Read More